(CNN)Republicans trying to deal with the mushrooming impeachment crisis are asking Donald Trump for something it may be impossible for him ever to deliver: the message discipline of his predecessor Bill Clinton.
They want consistency from a President ready to ignore distractions and dedicated to governing as they seek to impose order on his chaotic impeachment defense. And GOP lawmakers who are being asked to save Trump’s presidency also want more structure and coherence from a White House that has always reflected the President’s own disorderly and improvisational character.But, to succeed, this strategy would require Trump to abandon the most dominant traits of his unchained personality and political method — the qualities that led him to fame and fortune, powered his unlikely political rise and made him America’s most unusual President.Republican senators urged Trump to emulate the example of the former Democratic President during his own impeachment drama in the late 1990s when they met him at the White House on Thursday, according to Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina.The idea that Trump, always his own most vehement advocate, would swallow his fury and retreat behind a team of lawyers and professional political spinners is impossible to imagine. After all, he has effectively trashed the communications infrastructure that normal presidents use — preferring to handle everything himself in wild chats with reporters.Read MoreAnd the notion that the President would talk about anything other than impeachment and quietly get on with his job of governing — a task for which he has rarely shown much appetite in the first place — also seems fantastical in the extreme. Yet that is what Graham, a South Carolina Republican, effectively asked the President to do on Thursday.Graham was asked about the White House’s frequently changing impeachment messaging by a reporter Thursday, and quipped “Have you noticed?” before going on to praise Clinton — the man Graham tried to oust from office as a House impeachment manager two decades ago.”What he did is he had a team that was organized, had legal minds that could understand what was being said versus the legal proceedings in question,” Graham said.”And they were on message every day.”Graham argued that Clinton defended himself but never stopped being President and that was the key to his survival and eventual acquittal in a Senate trial.”The public may not have liked what the President had done but believed that he was still able to do his job … I’m hoping that will become the model here.”Clinton’s approval rating as measured by Gallup stayed high for all of the Monica Lewinsky saga, peaking at 73% in December 1998, the month he was impeached, a level never approached at any time by Trump.In his book, “The Clinton Tapes,” based on contemporaneous conversations with the President, the historian Taylor Branch paraphrased the former commander-in-chief’s mindset.”His best course was to concentrate on his job. He had no higher aspirations for the present, but he thought detachment was the best antidote for cynicism in the long run.”It is hard to imagine Trump showing detachment about anything — let alone an impeachment process he sees as an extension of a radical Deep State conspiracy to eject him from power.Trump cannot abandon what got him to the Oval OfficeThe President’s instinct is always to stoke controversy and outrage that acts not just as a distraction but whips up a storm that forces everyone else off balance as he stands unscathed in its eye.Trump’s daily Twitter screeds are not just a sideshow. They are the key to his presidency — it’s how he shapes a political narrative and connects with his army of fervent, loyal voters.And the off-the-cuff diversions at campaign rallies are just as important. Since Trump has decided to govern on behalf of his base alone, he needs to keep his supporters in a constant state of outrage that will drive them to the polls next year.Trump also did appear to have success in using his unconventional methods to discredit Robert Mueller and what the President described as his investigating team of “angry Democrats.” So it might be hard for anyone to convince him that dumping his belligerent instincts on impeachment represents his best possible strategy.After all, his unconventional willingness to stay permanently on the attack and rejecting the guardrails of political correctness is the behavior that makes him appealing to his voters and cements the bedrock of the political base that sustains him.And more than that, it’s just who Trump is.The problem for the President is such a political approach may not be well suited to the biggest current challenge before him — looming impeachment and a likely Senate trial.The kind of constitutional arguments needed to finesse what appears to be increasingly damning abuses of power in Ukraine are better not communicated via tweet. And they need a coordinated message that has been lacking from the White House.”They just jump around day to day,” one GOP aide said.”It’s kind of whatever he tweets out in the morning, that is what they run with.”The President’s wild attacks on witnesses — he blasted “Never Trump Republicans” this week who criticize him as “human scum” — may also be counterproductive and alienate undecided Americans.And the most disastrous moments of Trump’s impeachment defense have actually come from the President and top aides who have developed a facility for shooting themselves in the foot.While Trump appeared to believe that the rough transcript of his July 25 call with Ukraine’s President was absolving — and released it — it actually appeared to show a quid pro quo in which he asked for investigations into 2016 Democrats and Joe Biden in return for military aid.And White House acting chief of staff Mick Mulvaney last week appeared to make the President’s exposure much worse by saying that such bargains were always part of foreign policy.“Get over it,” he said, in a comment that instantly became a centerpiece of the impeachment case against the President.Republicans take charge of impeachment defenseCNN reported on Thursday that Republican lawmakers were taking the reins of the effort to counter the Democratic impeachment push amid frustration at the White House’s haphazard approach.Their move comes at the end of the week in which testimony by the top US diplomat in Ukraine strengthened the case of Democrats who believe there is a case for Trump’s removal. The strategy involves more of an effort to discredit key witnesses and a more confrontational approach to the nuts and bolts of the Democratic inquiry process.Their switch comes as Democrats begin to strategize on holding open hearings at the end of the current witness deposition stage of the impeachment investigation.The rival approaches reflect the fact that impeachment is a political process that effectively becomes a battle for the hearts and minds of the American public.Republicans hope to present the process as partisan and unwarranted and an outrageous attempt to overthrow the results of a democratic election. They also have a new cause to unite behind as of Thursday evening, after it emerged that Attorney General William Barr’s investigation into the intelligence and origins of the FBI investigation of the Trump campaign during the 2016 election is now a criminal probe.Democrats want to build a case that Trump abuses his power so egregiously that he should be dismissed from office — and to ultimately convince voters he’s unfit for a second term.Like any campaign this requires a strategy, clearly defined goals and a commitment from everyone on the team to spell out the message and avoid diversions that can backfire politically.Graham, who was among senators who spent time with the President at the White House on Thursday, said that the group told Trump to “keep governing the country.”And he said officials at the other end of Pennsylvania Avenue admit that they need help with impeachment messaging.”I met with Mick Mulvaney. He said, ‘Keep talking to us. We’re getting there.’ Yes, the message has been received and they’re making corrective action.”But writing a new script is one thing. Getting the President to follow it is a task no one has ever managed before.
CNN’s Manu Raju, Lauren Fox, Jeremy Herb, Evan Perez and Phil Mattingly contributed to this article